| CHAPTER II - IMPLEMENTATION
OF THE COMMUNITY WORK PROGRAMME
310.
The Economic Community of West African States is one of the sub-
regional organisations most actively involved in conflict
prevention and management. Since 1990 when the Standing Mediation
Committee and the Ceasefire Monitoring Group (ECOMOG) were set up
in Liberia, ECOWAS has been working relentlessly to restore peace
to West Africa. Last year, the most notable development in the
sub-region was the advent on the political scene of democratically
elected regimes, particularly in Guinea-Bissau, Niger and Nigeria.
Although there has been a democratic transition in Senegal, the
situation in 2000 is not very cheering. Besides Sierra Leone,
where the peace process remains frail and painstaking, the tense
atmosphere prevailing between Guinea and Liberia has deteriorated
to a point where armed incursions have been made into Liberia and
Guinea.
311. The violence which
characterised the presidential election in Cote d'Ivoire,
following the military junta's bid to remain in power, raised
fears for the peace and security of the country and the
sub-region. However, despite these worrying developments in the
three countries, the actions taken by ECOWAS have been tangible
and we can only hope that they will yield dividends in the very
near future. COTE D'IVOIRE
312. The robust measures which the
Community had been taking since December 1999 to restore peace and
consolidate democracy in Cote d'Ivoire after the military takeover
had not met with support from the military authorities there.
After the very first meeting of the Mediation and Security Council
in December 1999, the ECOWAS Chairman sent several missions to the
country, to propose a schedule for the restoration of democratic
institutions . If this plan had been accepted, the bloody clashes
which left many dead and hundreds wounded would have been avoided.
The Mediation and Security Council met at Heads of State level and
made recommendations which were approved by the Authority. The
junta still did not accept these recommendations and the matter
was therefore referred to the OAU at its last summit in Lome.
313. In this uneasy atmosphere,
with the issue of the eligibility of candidates to the
presidential elections hanging heavy on the air, the Heads of
State of the OAU Committee of Ten, comprising Algeria, Djibouti,
Gabon, Ghana, Mali, Nigeria, Senegal, South Africa and Togo,
undertook a visit to Cote d'Ivoire on 25 September 2000. The
purpose of this visit was to make proposals to the Ivorian
authorities with regard to the election time-table, and a number
of other mechanisms aimed at building up trust between fellow
Ivorians. The proposals included the creation of an Interim
Council to be presided over by President Robert Guei, in
conjunction with the leaders of the main political parties, and
also provided for a more extended transition period and the
postponement of the presidential elections, and the holding of
legislative elections.
314. The move made by the Committee
of Ten was highly commended by the Ministerial meeting of the
Mediation and Security Council which took place in Abuja on 4
October 2000.
315. Despite the efforts of the
Committee of Ten, the Constitutional Chamber of the Supreme Court
decided to disqualify 10 candidates, among them the candidates of
the PDCI-RDA and the RDR.
316. It was against this background
that the presidential elections were organised on 20 October 2000
with five candidates, including General Robert Guei, in the
running. Midway into vote counting, General Guei dissolved the
national electoral commission and proclaimed himself President.
From Bamako, ECOWAS issued a press release condemning this attempt
at vote rigging, and demanding that the will of the people be
respected. Following this blatant show of electoral fraud,
Ivorians, especially those in Abidjan, defied the security forces
and the presidential guard, took to the streets and succeeded in
removing General Guei from power. In the wake of this popular
uprising, the national electoral commission declared that Laurent
Gbagbo , the FPI candidate, had won the presidential elections
with 59.36% of the votes against 32.7% for General Guei. Mr.
Alassane Ouattara's party, the RDR, contested the results of the
election, stating that the election process had been flawed from
the start. Clashes then erupted which unfortunately assumed ethnic
and religious overtones. Dozens were killed while hundreds more
were wounded.
317. Amidst the continuing tension,
the ECOWAS Chairman despatched a delegation to Abidjan on 24
October 2000 comprising the Malian Minister of Foreign Affairs,
Chairman of the Mediation and Security Council, and the ECOWAS
Executive Secretary. They held separate meetings with His
Excellency Laurent Gbagbo, who had just been sworn in as
President, and with Messrs. Alassane Ouattara, the RDR Chairman,
and Laurent Dona Fologo, Chairman of the PDCI-RDA. It was obvious
from these three meetings that all wished : to
stop the violence to organise
legislative elections in accordance with the agreed election
schedule.
318. These major preoccupations
were foremost on the minds of Messrs. Laurent Gbagbo and Alassane
Ouattara when they met on 25 October 2000 to seek ways of ending
the spiral of violence. Indeed, the gravity of the crisis was
brought home even more forcefully on 26 October with the discovery
of a mass grave.
319. Now that President Gbagbo has
been sworn in and all the other political parties appear to have
accepted the legislative election, the topmost priority for Cote
d'Ivoire is to heal wounds and to mend fences. President Gbagbo
and the other leaders have stated as much in their utterances. Our
Community must give every support to these reconciliation efforts
and take every measure to safeguard the unity of the Ivorian
people.
B. GUINEA/LIBERIA/SIERRA LEONE
320. Relations between Guinea and
Liberia have not really improved despite the efforts of ECOWAS and
the Mano River Union. In the last few years, the two countries
have, on several occasions, accused one another of harbouring
large numbers of dissidents in their respective territories and
supporting their subversive activities.
321. Repeated attacks by armed
rebels from Sierra Leone on the Guinean villages of Massadou,
Pamalap and Macenta, and on Lofa County in northern Liberia,
particularly the towns of Zorzora and Voinjama, have resulted in
severe loss of life and destruction of property. The victims of
this violence include an official of the United Nations High
Commissioner for Refugees. During one such attack, another
official from the same organisation was kidnapped in Macenta in
Guinea but was later released. The violence has spawned thousands
of displaced persons.
322. The Guinean authorities have
condemned the incursions by armed rebels from Sierra Leone into
Guinean territory. Several of the attacks resulting in loss of
life are suspected to be the work of armed groups from the rebel
Sierra Leone Revolutionary United Front (RUF), the militia, and
other groups which have infiltrated the refugee population.
323. Humanitarian organisations
have relocated their bases to less exposed areas, for the
protection of their field officers. This measure is likely to
cause a deterioration in humanitarian services in the conflict
zones, which is regrettable in view of the fact that Guinea alone
shelters hundreds of thousands of refugees, indeed, the greatest
number in the entire sub-region.
324. It is against this backdrop
that the Ministers of Defence and Security of the member countries
of the Mano River Union, meeting in Bamako on 16 September 2000,
at the initiative of the current Chairman of the ECOWAS Authority,
agreed on the following : to
desist from issuing any media reports which are likely to
aggravate the situation; to
refrain from any act of harassment, questioning or expulsion
against groups of foreign nationals or any other acts of reprisal
against these peoples; to
ensure safety of life and property and guarantee free movement;
to
desist from launching border attacks from bases located inside
Mano River Union countries; to
desist from any act of provocation at common borders; to
normalise relations between the three countries; to
treat refugees in conformity with the provisions of the Geneva
Convention.
325. The Ministerial meeting of the
Mano River Union, held on 16 September 2000, further recommended
the following precautionary measures: removal of refugee camps
from border areas; the deployment of joint border security
patrols; an exchange of lists of subversives to facilitate their
immediate expulsion, and speedy signature of the tripartite
agreement on the reinsertion of displaced persons and repatriation
of refugees to their countries of origin.
326. The 4th Ministerial
meeting of the ECOWAS Security and Mediation Council, having
concluded discussions on the situation between Guinea, Liberia and
Sierra Leone, and anxious to find a solution to the increasingly
disquieting security conditions between the three sister
countries, endorsed the recommendations enumerated above, and
urged that a meeting of the Joint Security Committee of the Mano
River Union should be convened in Sierra Leone without delay. The
Mediation and Security Council also advised that joint committee
to take necessary measures to ensure, on the one hand, that the
Technical Committee finalises and submits its report on the
alleged attacks launched against Liberia from Guinean territory,
and on the other, to investigate the allegations of attacks
launched against Guinea from Liberia and Sierra Leone.
327. The 4th Ministerial
meeting of the ECOWAS Mediation and Security Council further
recommended to the Authority of Heads of State and Government to
speedily deploy a military observer mission along the land and sea
borders of Guinea and Liberia. The current ECOWAS Chairman, the
President of the Republic of Guinea, and the President of the
Federal Republic of Nigeria decided, on 8 October 2000, to
expedite an advance team to the spot, to determine the modalities
for the deployment of military observers. The Heads of State also
set up an ECOWAS technical committee to carry out all the
necessary investigations into the deepening of the crisis along
the Guinea/Liberia and Guinea/Sierra Leone borders. The advance
party comprising 11 officers, including 5 from Nigeria, 5 from
Mali and 1 from the Executive Secretariat left Abuja on 9 November
2000.
328. We are grateful for the
commendable action of Gambia, Mali, Nigeria and Senegal which have
undertaken to contribute troops to the observer mission. I ask all
the other ECOWAS Member States to emulate the example of these
countries, and appeal to the international community to provide
logistical and financial assistance for this mission.
329. The Community also owes a debt
of gratitude to Their Excellencies Gnassingbe Eyadema, President
of the Republic of Togo and current OAU Chairman, Alpha Oumar
Konare, President of the Republic of Mali and current Chairman of
ECOWAS, President Ahmad Tejan Kabbah of the Republic of Sierra
Leone, and President Olusegun Obasanjo of the Federal Republic of
Nigeria, for their efforts in organising separate consultations
with the presidents of Guinea and Liberia.
C. SIERRA LEONE
330. The 23rd session of
the Authority of Heads of State and Government set up the ECOWAS
Committee on Sierra Leone, in the hope of effecting a ceasefire in
the country. The committee decided the actions to be undertaken in
order to secure the release of the remaining hostages, and agreed
to send two regional fact-finding missions to investigate the
resumption of hostilities and the diamond traffic respectively.
331. A ceasefire has still not been
achieved in Sierra Leone, despite the fact that it would
facilitate the cessation of hostilities, the redeployment of
Revolutionary United Front fighters to their positions at the date
of the signing of the Lome Peace Agreement, and would permit the
restitution of weapons, ammunition and equipment seized by the RUF
from members of the United Nations Mission to Sierra Leone,
UNAMSIL.
332. The mission to Freetown
conducted by the Ceasefire Committee from 14 to 20 June 2000
yielded meagre results, mainly because of its inability to satisfy
the demands presented to it, and the absence of credible
representatives from the RUF, capable of giving commitments and
standing by them.
333. The new RUF leader,
''General'' Issa Sesay, took over from the founding leader of the
movement, Foday Sankoh, on 21 August 2000. The 4th
meeting of the Mediation and Security Council acknowledged the
need to maintain the momentum created by this new appointment at
all costs and called for the immediate reactivation of the ECOWAS
Ceasefire Committee.
334. Some of the equipment seized
from the UNAMSIL soldiers by the RUF have been returned, and the
Front has promised to return the rest without delay. As a sign of
good faith, the Sierra Leonean government agreed to the release of
171 detained RUF men who were not involved in the renewed outbreak
of hostilities.
335. The 21 hostages still in the
hands of the RUF were released through the good offices of His
Excellency Charles Ghankay Taylor, President of the Republic of
Liberia. UNAMSIL, meanwhile, carried out a successful rescue
operation, which ended on 17 July 2000 with the liberation of the
233 Indian blue berets who had been surrounded by the RUF
fighters. I wish to seize this opportunity to commend the Blue
Berets on their professionalism and their courage without which
these missions could not have been successfully carried out.
336. The Mediation and Security
Council has called on Member States which have not already done so
to forward to the ECOWAS Executive Secretariat the names of their
representatives on the regional fact-finding commissions.
337. The Heads of State and
Government of the ECOWAS Committee on Sierra Leone held a joint
meeting with the United Nations Secretary General on 10 July 2000,
during the OAU summit. It was agreed at this meeting that a
coordinating mechanism should be set up to harmonise the UN and
ECOWAS strategies. Indeed, if the efforts to bring about peace in
Sierra Leone are to prove successful, the Government of Sierra
Leone, ECOWAS and the UN will need to work in close collaboration.
338. The coordinating mechanism
held its first meeting in New York on 11 September 2000, at which
time it proceeded to evaluate progress in the peace process in
Sierra Leone, examine the status of humanitarian services in the
country, and the modalities for resuming implementation of the
Lome Peace Agreement.
339. It should be noted that
preparations are in progress to establish a special Tribunal for
Sierra Leone, and consultations have also been initiated between
the UN and the Sierra Leone government on the draft statutes for
the Tribunal.
D. RESPECT OF CHILDREN'S RIGHTS
AND PROTECTION OF WAR-AFFECTED
CHILDREN
340. The ongoing conflicts have led
to the deaths of thousands of children while armed bandits have
conscripted several thousands into their bands, thus depriving
them of education and a comfortable life. The conflicts have made
it impossible for tens of thousands of children in our sub-region
to have access to the basic services necessary for their health or
survival, and have denied them their rights.
341. The military obviously need to
be educated about the rights of children before, during and after
conflicts, in order to acquaint them with the United Nations
Convention on the Rights of the Child and the OAU Charter on
Children's Rights and Welfare. It is essential that concrete steps
be taken to raise their awareness on ways of sparing children the
most serious repercussions of conflicts. For this reason, a
military training seminar was jointly organised in Zambakro,
Republic of Cote d'Ivoire, in June 2000 by the Executive
Secretariat and the non-governmental organisation, "Save the
Children."
342. Following the ECOWAS
ministerial meeting held in Accra on 27 and 28 April 2000, the
Government of Canada organised an international conference on
children's rights and the protection of children in Winnipeg on 16
and 17 September, 2000 . The conference subscribed to an
international programme on war-affected children based on the
following principles which should guide activities in the
immediate and short terms: our
leadership should assume responsibilities for the protection of
children; all
commitments should be met; in particular, all conventions on the
protection of children in conflict situations should be signed,
ratified and implemented; all
to assume greater responsibilities, and an end should be put to
the perpetration of criminal acts with impunity; the Statutes of
the International Criminal Court should be signed, ratified and
implemented; an
end to child enslavement; steps should be taken to protect
children against murder, mutilation, torture, conscription, rape,
exploitation, kidnapping, and any other serious violation of the
fundamental freedoms and rights of children before, during and
after conflicts; the
release, disarmament, demobilisation and social reintegration of
conscripted children; access
to war-affected children ; emphasis
to be laid on prevention of conflicts; elimination
of sources of arms ; promotion
of children's health, welfare and education; long-term
concerted action by the international community through
co-ordination of sustained and concrete initiatives; involvement
of the youth in the peace process, and formulation of policies and
programmes designed to ensure their re-adaptation, reintegration
and education.
343. I am therefore appealing to
all Member States which have not done so yet, to sign and ratify,
or to accede to the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the
Child, which was adopted by the General Assembly on 20 November,
1989.
344. It is my hope that Member
States and the institutions of our Community will use the
above-mentioned principles as guidelines for the implementation of
actions to protect the welfare of the children of our sub-region
and, in particular, the welfare of war-affected children.
345. Early in 2001, the Executive
Secretariat, will, for its part, make every effort to set up a
child protection office in its premi ses ,with the assistance of
Canada. I wish to take this occasion to reiterate our appreciation
to the Swedish non-governmental organisation, "Save the
Children," and to the Canadian Government for their
assistance to war-affected children in our sub-region.
E. CONTROL OF ILLICIT SMALL ARMS
TRAFFICKING AND PROLIFERATION
346. As part of measures to prevent
conflicts and ensure a secure environment for our populations,
provision has been made in the ECOWAS mechanism to combat illicit
small arms trafficking and proliferation. The quantity of arms
outside the control of the authorities in West Africa is estimated
at eight million. Most of such arms fuel conflicts in the
sub-region and encourage crime in our major cities.
347. The Moratorium on the
Importation, Exportation and Manufacture of Light Weapons,
declared by the Authority of Heads of State and Government on 31
October, 1998 for a renewable period of three years, was the
starting point of the sub-regional crusade against illicit light
weapons trafficking and proliferation.
348. Since then, my Secretariat has
been working with assistance from the Programme for Co-ordination
and Assistance for Security and Development, (PCASED) on actions
identified within the nine priority activities adopted by the
Ministers of Foreign Affairs on 27 March 1999.
349. These priority activities
include the establishment, by each Member State, of a national
commission on the control of illicit light weapons trafficking and
proliferation, and the harmonisation of laws on such arms. So far,
however, only five Member States have set up their national
commissions. The other Member States which have failed to set up
theirs and so do not have an appropriate structure for processing
applications from individuals wishing to acquire arms and
ammunition covered by the moratorium.
350. I wish to take this
opportunity to renew my appeal to the Member States concerned to
set up their national commissions without delay and ensure that
they are made functional.
351. The various departments in the
Secretariat have , on many occasions, requested Member States to
forward their current legislation on arms for harmonisation. Most
Member States have not done so and the harmonisation process has
thus been unable to progress. I therefore urge those Member States
that have not done so yet, to forward their current legislation on
arms.
F. DESTRUCTION OF ARMS
352. The Executive Secretariat was
pleased to have been able to witness the ceremony marking the
"Flame of Peace"to which it was invited by the
Government of Niger. The destruction of arms through incineration,
which took place at Agadez on 25 September, 2000, was the crowning
achievement of a long negotiations between the rebel groups and
the central authority. You will recall that the Republic of Niger
experienced four years of armed rebellion and that three
agreements between the Government and the erstwhile resistance
army had to be signed before peace was finally restored to the
entire Niger territory. The Code of Conduct for the implementation
of the ECOWAS moratorium stipulates that Member States shall
destroy all arms , ammunition and spare parts collected pursuant
to peace agreements.
G. IMPLEMENTATION OF THE
PROTOCOL RELATING TO THE
MECHANISM FOR CONFLICT PREVENTION, MANAGEMENT,
RESOLUTION, PEACEKEEPING AND
SECURITY
Ratification of the
Protocol relating to the
Mechanism
353. Current happenings on the
political scene underscore all too clearly the crucial importance
of the protocol relating to the mechanism, which the Authority of
Heads of State and Government adopted on 10 December, 1999 and
which entered into force, provisionally, upon signature. It is,
therefore, desirable that Member States ratify it without delay to
enable its definitive entry into force.
Mediation and Security
Council.
354. The Protocol has made it
possible for ECOWAS to avoid having to resort to ad hoc conflict
resolution procedures. This task is now assigned to the Mediation
and Security Council which has met a number of times at the
ministerial level, and once at the level of Heads of State and
Government . It has not yet met at the ambassadorial level because
a number of Member States have not yet accredited their
ambassadors to ECOWAS. In view of the fact that Mediation and
Security Council meetings at the ambassadorial level are easier to
convene and more frequent than ministerial meetings, this organ
will undoubtedly play a crucial role in conflict prevention and
management. Council of Elders
355. This Council has not yet been
established because a number of Member States are yet to react to
my repeated appeals to them to send in the names of persons who
can be included in the list of Council members.
356. In order to avoid any further
delay in the establishment of the Council, I have decided to
submit the names of persons already received to the forthcoming
Mediation and Security Council meeting, to enable it make
appropriate recommendations for consideration by the Authority of
Heads of State and Government. Stand-by
Units
357. The inaugural meeting of the
Defence and Security Commission, held in Accra on 19 and 20 July
2000, made relevant recommendations on the size of the model
stand-by units provided for in the protocol relating to the
mechanism, and on their training strategy. The proposals were
endorsed by the fourth meeting of the Mediation and Security
Council held in Abuja on 4 October 2000. I have despatched a
technical team to Member States to ensure that these units are
effectively put in place since they will now make up ECOMOG. Visit
by a United Nations Security Council
Delegation to the Executive
Secretariat
358. A United Nations Security
Council delegation visited the Executive Secretariat on 13 October
2000 to discuss issues pertaining to peace and security in West
Africa, with particular emphasis on the situation in Sierra Leone
and along the Guinea/Liberia and Guinea/Sierra Leone borders. The
delegation also discussed ways and means of solidifying the
existing partnership between ECOWAS and the United Nations through
concerted conflict resolution efforts in the sub-region. The
eleven-member delegation, led by the British Ambassador to the
United Nations, also included representatives of the other
permanent Security Council members: the United States, France and
Russia, as well as representatives of Bangladesh, Canada, Jamaica,
Mali, the Netherlands and Ukraine.
H. RATIONALISATION OF THE
AGREEMENT ON NON - AGGRESSION
AND DEFENCE (ANAD)
359. In compliance with the various
decisions of the Authority regarding the rationalisation of all
IGOs within our sub-region, a meeting was held between ECOWAS and
ANAD on 25 February 2000 to recommend ways and means of
rationalising the activities of ANAD in order to avoid its
activities clashing with those of ECOWAS.
360. That meeting proposed two
options for effecting the rationalisation namely:
a) The conversion of ANAD into a
specialised Agency of ECOWAS with a specific mandate;
b) The absorption of ANAD into the
ECOWAS Secretariat.
I. SUPPORT FOR DEMOCRACY IN
MEMBER STATES
361. In demonstration of the
Community's commitment to the ECOWAS Declaration of Political
Principles of 6 July 1991 on freedom, peoples rights and
democratisation, the Executive Secretariat monitors as much as
possible all pre and post election procedures in Member States: On
23 December 1999 the Secretariat witnessed the swearing in of
President Tandja Mamadou of the Republic of Niger after the
successful democratic elections in that State.
ii) The Secretariat was also in the
Republic of Guinea Bissau for the elections that brought President
Koumba Yala Kobde Nhanca to power in February, 2000.
362. Under the leadership of
President Tandja Mamadou of Niger and President Nhanca of Guinea
Bissau, the economies of both countries have changed for the
better, bringing an improvement in the life of their peoples. The
Secretariat was in Senegal to monitor the elections which brought
in President Abdul Wade on 19 March 2000.
363. These elections were fair,
peaceful and transparent, and I believe that they truly represent
a triumph for democracy and the Community. I enjoin all Member
States due to organise democratic elections to emulate the example
set by the Republic of Senegal.
364. I cannot but praise the
conduct of the presidential contestants in the elections in
Senegal. The winner accepted victory with commendable modesty,
while the other candidate accepted defeat with a high sense of
responsibility. |